Dinosaur News: Fossil footprints of Ruopodosaurus clava reveal mid-Cretaceous ecosystem

Footprint Fossils Reveal Mid-Cretaceous Ecosystem

Crumbling footprint lizard

Published:

A new species of ankylosaurid footprint fossil, "Ruopodosaurus clava", from the mid-Cretaceous period has been discovered in rock formations in Canada.

Until now, no ankylosaurid fossils had been found in North America from the mid-Cretaceous period, leading it to be considered a "fossil record gap." However, the discovery of this large-scale trackway has revealed their presence and ecology on the North American continent at that time.

  • A discovery that fills the gap: Proving they certainly existed even in environments where bones were not preserved.
  • Evidence of niche partitioning: Sympatric coexistence and habitat segregation of nodosaurids and ankylosaurids.
  • Harsh struggle for survival: Vivid footprint records of giant crocodiles and pack-hunting tyrannosaurs.

On this page, we explain how these footprint fossils were preserved and in what kind of environment Ruopodosaurus clava coexisted with other dinosaurs, based on the latest research.

Introduction: The "Gap" in the Mid-Cretaceous Fossil Record and Discoveries via Trace Fossils

The fossil record of the North American continent has played a crucial role in unraveling the history and geographical distribution of dinosaurs during the Cretaceous period of the Mesozoic era. In particular, it is known that a rich terrestrial ecosystem existed in the western North American continent during the Late Cretaceous (about 84 to 66 million years ago), inhabited by numerous ceratopsians, ornithopods, theropods, and thyreophorans (ankylosaurs) such as Ankylosaurus.

However, in the rock formations of the preceding "mid-Cretaceous" period (about 100 to 84 million years ago), there was a "fossil record gap" (Ghost lineage / Fossil gap) where the skeletal records of specific dinosaurs were significantly lacking.

Among thyreophorans (ankylosaurs), skeletal fossils of the "Ankylosauridae" family, which possess a bony club at the tip of their tail (tail club), had never been found in North America from this mid-Cretaceous period. Therefore, the theory that they once disappeared from North America and migrated back from the Asian continent in a later era had been supported for a long time.

However, large-scale trackways measuring 100 meters, which overturn this established theory, were discovered in the rock formations of Tumbler Ridge in British Columbia and northwestern Alberta, Canada. An investigation by an international joint research team revealed that these were the footprints of an ankylosaurid with a "tridactyl (three-toed) hind limb," and it was formally described as a new ichnospecies, "Ruopodosaurus clava," in 2025. We will explain the ecosystem of that time revealed by these footprint fossils.

Features of the New Footprint Fossil: Ruopodosaurus clava

Image of Ruopodosaurus clava footprints
Mid-Cretaceous ecosystem restored from footprints
Gemini Generated Image

The genus name Ruopodosaurus means "crumbling footprint lizard," named after the crumbly terrain of the discovery site. The specific name clava means "club" in Latin, indicating that the dinosaur that left the footprints possessed the tail club characteristic of the Ankylosauridae family.

A detailed examination of the footprint shapes reveals that the hind limbs were distinctly "three-toed," and the tips of each toe were blunt triangles or U-shapes to support heavy body weight. The forelimbs had five crescent-curved toes. These features perfectly match the skeletal structure of ankylosaurids discovered in China from the same period.

The estimated total length of this dinosaur, inferred from the width and stride of the footprints, was about 5 to 6 meters. Although smaller than the giant Ankylosaurus that appears in a later era, it is thought to have had armor robust enough to be considered a "walking tank."

Table 1: Comparison of Ichnotaxa and Inferred Thyreophorans
Ichnotaxon Inferred Trackmaker Pes Digits (Hind limb) Manus Digits (Forelimb) Morphological Features of Digits Occurrence Period in North America
Tetrapodosaurus borealis Nodosauridae Tetradactyl (4 toes) Pentadactyl (5 toes) Slightly elongated, acutely angled tips Early to Mid-Cretaceous
Ruopodosaurus clava Ankylosauridae Tridactyl (3 toes) Pentadactyl (5 toes) Blunt triangle or U-shaped tips Mid-Cretaceous (Cenomanian)

Why Were "Bones" Not Found, but Only "Footprints" Remained?

The greatest significance of the discovery of Ruopodosaurus footprints is that it proved the definite existence of the Ankylosauridae family in mid-Cretaceous North America. They had not temporarily gone extinct in North America.

So, why was not a single bone fossil found for 16 million years? The answer lay in the relationship between the "environment" where they lived and the preservability of fossils.

Taphonomic Bias (Bias in preservation during the fossilization process):
In the process from when an organism dies to when it becomes a fossil, environmental conditions dictate that some things are easily preserved while others are not. This is called taphonomic bias. The fact that footprints remain clearly is absolute proof that the animal was definitely in that location, even if its skeleton is not preserved.

Western Canada at that time was a lowland delta plain with braided rivers and plant-rich wetlands (floodplains). For footprints to be preserved, the mud on the ground must be neither too soft nor too hard. In this region, there was a cycle of water receding and moderately drying out, making it the perfect environment for footprint molds to be left behind.

On the other hand, in wetlands abundant with plants, soil and water tend to become highly acidic as plants decompose. When a dinosaur dies in such an environment, its bones, made of calcium carbonate, dissolve rapidly. Furthermore, frequent floods would scatter the bones, making the probability of bone fossils remaining intact extremely low. In other words, the reason bones were not found was not because they "had gone extinct," but because it was "an environment where bones easily dissolved."

Coexistence and "Habitat Segregation" of Two Armored Dinosaurs

Another notable discovery in this study is that footprints of the four-toed Nodosauridae and the three-toed Ankylosauridae (Ruopodosaurus) were found together in the same floodplain environment.

As an ecological principle, two species with exactly the same lifestyle cannot coexist in the same place in the long term (competitive exclusion principle). The fact that these heavily armored giant herbivorous dinosaurs could coexist in the same area (sympatric coexistence) indicates that there was clear "niche partitioning" (habitat and dietary segregation) between them.

Browsers and Grazers:
Nodosaurids had relatively narrow snouts and were "browsers (selective foragers)" that picked specific ferns and other plants to eat. On the other hand, ankylosaurids had wide snouts and are inferred to have been "grazers (non-selective foragers)" that ate by indiscriminately cropping low-lying vegetation close to the ground.

Also, looking at the distribution of footprints, it has been pointed out that while nodosaurids preferred broad wetlands, ankylosaurids may have been skewed towards specific environments, such as being slightly further inland. Such differences in diet and subtle differences in habitat enabled their coexistence.

Struggle for Survival with Predators and Giant Crocodiles

Looking at the entire 100-meter-scale continuous trackway surface reveals how the floodplain of that time was shared by a diverse array of creatures.

Table 2: Ecological Network and Taxonomic Groups of the Time
Taxonomic Group Main Ichnotaxa / Traces Estimated Ecological Role Remarks
Ankylosauridae Ruopodosaurus clava Grazer of low-level vegetation New species, possesses a bony tail club
Nodosauridae Tetrapodosaurus borealis Browser Tetradactyl hind limbs, flexible tail
Theropoda (Tyrannosauridae) Parallel trackways of multiple individuals Apex Predator Pack hunting, suggestion of sociality
Giant Crocodyliformes Swim traces scratching the water bottom Apex predator of the aquatic realm Body length 9-12m, possibly Deinosuchus ancestors
Aves (Birds) Paxavipes babcockensis Small foragers of coastal areas Ecological niche similar to shorebirds

From the same area, footprints of three tyrannosaurs walking in the same direction at the same time have been discovered. This indicates the possibility that they were hunting in packs rather than alone. It is thought that the presence of such predators exerted an evolutionary pressure for ankylosaurids to develop heavy armor and tail clubs. The footprints also suggest the possibility that Ruopodosaurus did not just wander alone but sometimes formed herds to counter predators.

Even more remarkably, from rock formations indicating the remains of a shallow lake, swimming traces (claw scratch marks) of a giant crocodile estimated to reach 9 to 12 meters in length have been found alongside ankylosaur footprints. Even heavily armed ankylosaurs were at risk of surprise attacks from giant crocodiles lurking in the water when drinking, for example. The footprint fossils realistically reflect such a tense environment.

New Dinosaur Research Opened Up by Trace Fossils

The discovery of Ruopodosaurus in Canada splendidly filled the "gap" of missing skeletal fossils, bringing a historical turning point to mid-Cretaceous dinosaur ecology.

In recent years, new methods have been introduced, such as searching not only for footprint depressions but also using the raised mud pushed out around the footprint when stepping into it as an indicator. Trace fossils such as footprints are valuable records that prove life definitely existed and was active there, even in environments where bones would dissolve.

References

  • First tail-club dinosaur tracks found in Canadian Rockies | Courthouse News Service, https://www.courthousenews.com/first-tail-club-dinosaur-tracks-found-in-canadian-rockies/
  • 100-Million-Year-Old Footprints of Tail-Clubbed Armored Dinosaurs Discovered in Canada, https://www.sci.news/paleontology/ruopodosaurus-clava-footprints-13824.html
  • これまでの定説を覆す発見 世界で初めて見つかった3本指の恐竜の化石 - NewSphere, https://newsphere.jp/popular/20250422-02/
  • Mysterious 3-Toed Footprints in Canada Reveal New Ankylosaur Species - Science Alert, https://www.sciencealert.com/mysterious-3-toed-footprints-in-canada-reveal-new-ankylosaur-species
  • Tracking Giant Cretaceous Crocodiles and Tiny Ankylosaurs North of Tumbler Ridge, https://www.trmf.ca/news/tracking-giant-cretaceous-crocodiles-and-tiny-ankylosaurs-north-of-tumbler-ridge