About Spinosaurus
| Scientific Name (Genus) | Spinosaurus |
| Meaning of Name |
Spine lizard
spīna (spine) [Latin] - saurus (lizard) [Greek] |
| Classification | Saurischia, Theropoda, Tetanurae, Megalosauroidea, Spinosauridae |
| Total Length & Weight | Approx. 13-15m (over 14m for adults) / Estimated weight approx. 7,400kg |
| Diet | Piscivorous (an opportunistic predator that also preys on various waterside animals) |
| Period | Early to Late Cretaceous (Cenomanian stage, went extinct about 93.5 million years ago) |
| Sub-classification / Species Name |
Spinosaurus aegyptiacus
Spinosaurus mirabilis Spinosaurus maroccanus (possible nomen dubium or synonym) |
| Year of Paper Publication | 1915 |
| Genus Name Publication |
Ergebnisse der Forshungsreisen Prof. E. Stromers in den Wüsten Ägyptents.
Wirbeltier-Reste der Baharîe-Stufe(unterstes Cenoman) 3.Das Original des Theropoden Spinosaurus aegyptiacus, von Ernst Stromer, Vorgelegt am 6, Nov. 1915. |
Characteristics and Evolution: A giant piscivorous dinosaur that expanded from Europe to Africa
Spinosaurus is one of the largest theropods in history, reaching over 14m in length and an estimated weight of 7,400 kg (7.4 tons) as an adult. With a giant sail (neural spines) up to 1-2m high on its back, a long, slender snout, and straight, conical teeth, it was highly adapted to a fish diet in waterside and shallow environments. Because of the tragic history of its specimen being destroyed in WWII, it was long called a "phantom dinosaur," but with recent discoveries and analyses, its appearance continues to change more dramatically than any other dinosaur.
European origin and divergence into two subfamilies
The origin of the Spinosauridae was once shrouded in mystery, but a series of recent fossil discoveries in the Iberian Peninsula (Spain and Portugal) has revealed its evolutionary path. In Early Cretaceous Europe, diverse spinosaurids lived, including Baryonyx, Iberospinus, Camarillasaurus, Vallibonavenatrix, Protathlitis, and Riojavenatrix.
Fossils of Iberospinus, in particular, show that the Spinosauridae were already adapted to a waterside (semi-aquatic) environment from a very early stage of evolution. These relatives, born in the coastal and lagoon environments of Europe, later expanded into the African continent (then northern Gondwana) multiple times, where they achieved further gigantism.
Spinosauridae are broadly divided into two groups based on skull and tooth characteristics: the "Baryonychinae" and the "Spinosaurinae". This reflects differences in prey size and eating methods, i.e., the division of roles (niche partitioning) within the ecosystem.
| Morphological Features | Baryonychinae | Spinosaurinae |
|---|---|---|
| Tooth structure | Fine serrations on the edges of the teeth, with vein-like patterns on the enamel surface. | Serrations are completely degenerated or lost, and they have a smooth conical shape. |
| Number of teeth | High number of teeth, with over 20 in the upper jaw and over 25 in the lower jaw (dentary). | Decreased number of teeth, with about 12 in the upper jaw and about 15 in the lower jaw. |
| Position of snout and nostrils | The retraction of the nostrils (external nares) is limited to the anterior half of the upper jaw. | Nostrils have retracted far to the back of the skull. Has a long constriction behind the tip of the snout (rosette structure). |
Thus, the evolution from the "flesh-slicing serrated teeth" of the Baryonychinae to the "smooth conical teeth that pierce and hold prey" of the Spinosaurinae indicates a shift from general carnivory to an ecology that primarily feeds on fish while targeting diverse waterside prey.
"Hand claws" to draw prey in, and "flat foot claws" to walk on mud
Spinosaurus's forelimbs were robust from the shoulder down, and the thumb (digit I) was equipped with a massive, curved claw. According to biomechanical analyses (models using the principle of leverage), this huge hand claw is thought to have functioned not for slicing prey's flesh, but as a "hook" to deeply snag and forcefully pull in and secure large, struggling fish that could not be held down by the jaws alone.
On the other hand, the claws of the hindlimbs (foot claws) had the exact opposite characteristics of the hand claws. In 2018, a fossil of an extremely small foot claw, only 21mm long (specimen number: MSNM V6894), was reported from the Kem Kem Group in Morocco. This is a fossil of a juvenile (baby) Spinosaurus, with an estimated total length of only 1.78m, of an animal that exceeds 14m as an adult.
Surprisingly, this juvenile foot claw had the exact same "flat and wide bottom" shape as the adult claw (130mm long). Unlike the strongly curved foot claws of typical carnivorous dinosaurs, Spinosaurus's flat claws and broad feet served the role of dispersing its weight on mud and soft sediments to walk without sinking, as well as assisting in paddling in the water.
A growth pattern in which the proportions of body parts remain unchanged from childhood to adulthood is called "isometric growth". The surface of the 1.78m juvenile fossil revealed numerous small pores (nutrient foramina) indicating rapid bone formation, which is also seen in juveniles of modern birds and crocodilians. This proves that from an early stage shortly after hatching, Spinosaurus adapted to a life of walking on soft mud by the water just like adults, growing into a giant body through an S-curve-like growth process.
Secrets of the head and jaws: Sensors and mechanical structures that never let underwater prey escape
There are many holes at the tip of the snout.
They served as sensors to detect fish as food.
The skull of Spinosaurus has undergone a unique evolution vastly different from other large theropods like Tyrannosaurus and Carcharodontosaurus. Its snout is very elongated, but not flattened vertically like modern crocodiles; instead, it has a laterally compressed, vertically flat structure, as if crushed from the sides.
Furthermore, the tips of the upper and lower jaws spread out slightly like a spoon, forming a structure called a "rosette" where giant teeth are concentrated. Right behind the rosette of the upper jaw is a deep notch, and when the mouth is closed, the teeth of the expanded tip of the lower jaw fit perfectly into this notch. This jaw shape is surprisingly similar not only to modern gharials and false gharials but also to the jaws of Triassic aquatic reptiles called "phytosaurs" and modern tropical fish like "pike congers".
The phenomenon in which completely unrelated organisms evolve into similar body shapes as a result of adapting to similar environments or lifestyles is called "convergent evolution". The rosette-structured jaw of Spinosaurus was the ultimate answer evolution derived to the common challenge of "reliably catching slippery, fast-moving fish in dark, poor-visibility water."
Also, studies using CT scans and computational mechanical simulations (finite element analysis) revealed that Spinosaurus's elongated snout, contrary to its fragile appearance, possessed strength against "bending" and "torsion" equal to or greater than that of modern crocodilians of the same size. Although it did not have the immense bite force to crush bones like Tyrannosaurus, it was specialized for quickly closing its jaws, deeply piercing its conical teeth into prey, withstanding the twisting forces of struggling prey, and pushing them into the back of its throat.
Even more noteworthy are the countless small holes (neurovascular foramina) opening at the tip of the snout. Examining the inside of the skull with CT scans revealed a highly complex and advanced network of nerves and blood vessels connected to the "trigeminal nerve" spreading deep behind these holes. Spinosaurus hunted by keeping its retracted nostrils above water to continue breathing, sticking only the tip of its snout into the muddy water, and using this high-sensitivity sensor to detect the slight water pressure changes caused by swimming fish.
The forefront of the debate: A swimming dinosaur or a shallow water ambush hunter?
The question of "to what extent Spinosaurus was adapted to a life in water" has been one of the most hotly debated topics in modern paleontology since 2014. With new discoveries and physical counter-evidence successively published, its reconstructed image has swung wildly between the "fully aquatic pursuit predator" model and the "wading ambush (heron-like)" model.
2014-2022: Development of the "underwater pursuit predator" hypothesis
In 2014, Dr. Nizar Ibrahim and his research team analyzed a newly discovered skeletal specimen in Morocco (neotype specimen: FSAC-KK 11888) and announced that Spinosaurus's hindlimbs were extremely short compared to other large theropods. They calculated that its center of gravity was positioned far forward of its hips (pelvis), deducing that it could not walk bipedally on land and was forced into quadrupedal locomotion. Furthermore, because the insides of its limb bones lacked cavities (medullary cavities) and were densely packed, they claimed this was an adaptation to reduce buoyancy and dive, like penguins or manatees.
Moreover, when fossils of the tail of the same specimen were announced in 2020, it sent shockwaves worldwide. Spinosaurus's tail was not a long, thin rod like other dinosaurs, but a massive "paddle-like fin" shape with long spines (neural spines and chevrons) lining the top and bottom. When the research team attached a plastic model shaped like the tail to a robotic device and conducted water flow experiments, it demonstrated far greater propulsive force than the tails of other terrestrial dinosaurs, proposing that it was an "underwater pursuit predator" that actively chased fish by swinging its tail side-to-side in the water like crocodiles or newts.
Short hindlimbs
Subsequently, in 2022, Dr. Matteo Fabbri and his colleagues compared the compactness (bone density) of femurs and ribs from over 250 species of extant and extinct vertebrates using CT scans, reporting that the bone density of Spinosaurus and Baryonyx completely matches that of animals that dive underwater to forage, further reinforcing the underwater diving theory.
Biomechanical counter-evidence: Too buoyant to dive? The "shallow water heron" model
However, strong counter-evidence based on physics and biomechanics was presented by other research groups against this sensational hypothesis of a "freely diving and swimming dinosaur."
In 2021, Dr. David Hone and Dr. Thomas Holtz pointed out that because the muscle mass of Spinosaurus's tail was overwhelmingly less than that of a crocodile, and its massive body and back sail created extremely large water resistance (drag) underwater, it was fluid-dynamically impossible for it to chase fast-swimming fish underwater. Then in 2022, a research team led by Professor Paul Sereno of the University of Chicago created a "3D digital fleshed-out model" incorporating muscles, internal organs, and the volumes of lungs and air sacs into precise skeletal data based on CT scans, and announced their verification results.
| Verification Item | Underwater pursuit predator theory (Ibrahim et al. 2014, 2020 / Fabbri et al. 2022) |
Shallow wading (heron) theory (Hone & Holtz 2021 / Sereno et al. 2022) |
|---|---|---|
| Center of gravity and terrestrial walking | Center of gravity was in the middle of the torso; could not stand on hind legs on land and quadrupedal walking was essential. | As a result of correctly calculating the "space of lungs and air sacs" that was underestimated in the 2014 study, the center of gravity was over the hips (hindlimbs), and fully bipedal walking was possible on land. |
| Buoyancy and diving ability | High-density bones packed inside acted as "ballast," allowing it to dive deep and pursue prey. | Despite an estimated weight of about 7,400 kg, the air in the giant lungs and air sacs makes the overall body density significantly lower than seawater, so the buoyancy is too strong to sink underwater (diving impossible). |
| Swimming ability and stability | By swinging its paddle-like tail, it obtained powerful propulsion underwater. | Water resistance is too great, and it could only swim at a slow speed of less than 1m per second even at the surface. In depths where its feet could not touch the bottom, the giant back sail would tilt, making it very prone to rolling over (capsizing) and extremely unstable. |
| Reason for heavy bones (high-density bone) | An "adaptation to suppress buoyancy" peculiar to aquatic animals diving underwater. | A "mechanical reinforcement on land" thickening bone walls to prevent breaking in order to support a massive body exceeding 7 tons on land with short hindlimbs (its closely related species Suchomimus, which has a strong terrestrial tendency, also has dense bones). |
Furthermore, Professor Sereno and his team also cite the locations where fossils are found (geographical distribution) as evidence. While marine animals like whales and seals do not enter deep into narrow freshwater rivers to live, Spinosaurus fossils have been found in large numbers not only in coastal areas but also in freshwater environments like the inland basins of Niger, far from the coastline.
In February 2026, a new species, Spinosaurus mirabilis, possessing a scimitar-shaped crest about 50 cm high, was also reported from inland river strata in Niger by Professor Sereno's team. These lines of evidence support the theory that Spinosaurus was not swimming around at high speeds underwater, but was a semi-aquatic hunter (shallow wading model/hell heron model) that waded in shallows over 2m deep, thrusting its long neck and snout from above the water surface to ambush and prey on fish, like modern giant herons or storks.
The role of the back sail and the mystery of extinction due to sudden environmental change
The role of the sail (neural spines): Not for "thermoregulation" or as a "fin," but a "giant billboard"
Regarding the giant sail (elongated neural spines) on its back, the biggest symbol of Spinosaurus, it was once thought to play a role in "thermoregulation" similar to the back plates of the thyreophoran Stegosaurus. However, as a result of examining the surface and cross-sections of the sail bones in detail, almost no traces of blood vessels for exchanging heat were found, so the thermoregulation theory is currently rejected.
Also, a role like a dorsal fin to stabilize posture underwater was proposed, but the aforementioned fluid dynamics simulations revealed that diving underwater would cause significant resistance on the sail, leading to capsizing. Therefore, the most widely accepted theory currently is that both the giant back sail and the paddle-like expanded tail fin evolved as a "visual display" to show off one's presence and size to peers from afar in the open environments by the water, for territorial disputes and appealing to the opposite sex.
Why did they disappear in the middle of the Cretaceous?
In North Africa during the mid-Cretaceous, spinosaurids divided niches with terrestrial giant carnivorous dinosaurs like Carcharodontosaurus and prospered as apex predators of the waterside. However, bordering the end of the Late Cretaceous Cenomanian stage (about 93.5 million years ago), they suddenly disappeared from the fossil record (*some uncertain theories that they survived until the end of the Cretaceous are currently rejected as lacking sufficient evidence).
This sudden extinction coincides with a rapid global environmental change called the "Cenomanian-Turonian boundary event (Oceanic Anoxic Event 2: OAE 2)". At that time, the Earth experienced extreme global warming (Cretaceous Thermal Maximum), and intense fluctuations occurred, where sea levels rose rapidly (transgression) and then suddenly dropped (regression).
Spinosaurids had evolved to specialize in "water-rich and complex waterside ecosystems" such as vast delta zones, mangrove forests, and networks of rivers and lagoons. Creatures that are too specialized for a specific environment exhibit unparalleled strength while the environment is stable, but cannot survive when their habitat itself is lost due to rapid sea-level fluctuations. As a result, spinosaurids were forced to exit the global stage earlier than other carnivorous dinosaurs that could adapt to a wider range of terrestrial environments.
A history of discovery and loss: Fossils vanished in air raids and the mystery of classification
Source: Ergebnisse der Forshungsreisen Prof. E. Stromers in den Wüsten Ägyptents. Wirbeltier-Reste der Baharîe-Stufe(unterstes Cenoman) 3.Das Original des Theropoden Spinosaurus aegyptiacus, von Ernst Stromer, Vorgelegt am 6, Nov. 1915.
A great discovery in the Egyptian desert and "Spinosaurus B"
The research history of Spinosaurus is colored by strange fate and tragedy. In 1910, Ernst Stromer, a German aristocrat and paleontologist, set off on an expedition to the desert regions of Egypt. Overcoming difficulties such as quarantine measures due to a cholera outbreak on the steamboat he was aboard, he began surveying the Bahariya Oasis, about 320km southwest of Cairo.
In the fall of 1912, fossil collector Richard Markgraf, who was funded by Stromer, excavated an unknown giant theropod skeleton (specimen number: BSP 1912 VIII 19) from strata dating to the Late Cretaceous Cenomanian stage. Including a long, slender lower jaw, straight conical teeth, and long dorsal neural spines exceeding 1m, Stromer described this fossil in 1915 as a new genus and species Spinosaurus aegyptiacus, meaning "Egyptian spine lizard."
Furthermore, in 1914, a second partial skeleton (IPHG 1922 X45) was also excavated by Markgraf, but they were stranded in Egypt due to the outbreak of World War I. After Markgraf's death in 1916, the fossils finally reached Germany in 1922, severely damaged by repeated transport. Stromer described this as "Spinosaurus B" in 1934 and published a skeletal restoration drawing in 1936.
The tragedy of WWII: Rejected evacuation requests and the bombing of Munich
However, World War II dealt a devastating blow to Spinosaurus research. Stromer's collection of Egyptian fossils was kept at the Bavarian State Collection of Paleontology in Munich. Stromer, who was critical of the Nazi regime at the time, repeatedly begged the museum director, Karl Beurlen, to evacuate the precious fossils to safe locations like salt mines away from the intensifying danger of air raids.
However, Director Beurlen, a fervent Nazi supporter who believed "the German Luftwaffe will defend the cities," continued to reject Stromer's requests. As a result, the museum took a direct hit during the Royal Air Force (RAF) bombing of Munich on the night of April 24-25, 1944, and all fossils, including the type specimen of Spinosaurus, were completely burned to ashes. For Stromer, who had lost two sons on the front lines and had another taken to a Soviet camp, this was a tragedy in which he lost all his lifelong academic achievements. After that, until his miraculously surviving son Wolfgang donated a few record photographs to the museum in 1995, Spinosaurus existed only in the sketches of research papers.
Fossils from the Kem Kem Group and the classification debate surrounding "Sigilmassasaurus"
Since the 1990s, fossils of spinosaurids have been discovered again in the Kem Kem Group of Morocco. In 1996, paleontologist Dale Russell described a new species, "Spinosaurus maroccanus", and a new species of a different genus, "Sigilmassasaurus brevicollis", based on characteristic, very wide cervical (neck) vertebrae found in this region.
Since then, a fierce debate has continued between the single-species hypothesis (Dr. Ibrahim, Dr. Smith, et al.), which argues that spinosaurids inhabiting the Kem Kem Group of North Africa "are actually all a single species (Spinosaurus aegyptiacus), and Sigilmassasaurus, maroccanus, and even Oxalaia from Brazil are synonyms", and the multiple-species hypothesis (Dr. Evers et al.), which argues that "differences in the processes and structures of neck bones cannot be explained by individual variation or growth stages, and multiple separate genera and species like Sigilmassasaurus coexisted."
The process from when an organism dies until it becomes a fossil is called "taphonomy". In Morocco's Kem Kem Group, Spinosaurus teeth fossils are found in massive quantities to the point of being cheaply traded, but most skeletons were transported by strong river currents of the time and are found scattered in isolated pieces. Unless multiple complete, articulated skeletons are found, it is extremely difficult to conclusively prove whether differences in bone shape are because they are "different species" or just "differences in age, sex, or the sequence position of the neck bones" within the same species.